Object Oriented Pattern: JavaScript Classes and PHP Classes

I wrote an article on Understanding Prototypes and Inheritance in JavaScript for DigitalOcean, in which I explained how to use constructor functions and create new objects that inherit from them. I thought it would be interesting to rewrite the exact same code as a JavaScript ES6 class and a PHP class, and get the same output. So here is a side-by-side comparison of the same pattern and output in ES5, ES6, and PHP.

Using the ES6 classes, I'll explain what the pattern is doing.

We'll create a class (an object blueprint) and extend the class (inheritance). I'm using the RPG character classes for the example.

// Creating a class
class Hero {}

// Extending a class
class Warrior extends Hero {}

I'll add a constructor() function to assign two parameters to the class.

class Hero {
  // Assigning parameters with constructor
  constructor(name, level) {
    this.name = name
    this.level = level
  }
}

// Extending a class
class Warrior extends Hero {}

I'll add a method as well.

class Hero {
  constructor(name, level) {
    this.name = name
    this.level = level
  }

  // Adding a method
  greet() {
    return `${this.name} says hello.`
  }
}

class Warrior extends Hero {}

We'll edit the inherited class now, adding a new parameter. We use super() to access the parameters from the parent - otherwise the inherited class would not be able to access and work with them.

class Hero { ... }

class Warrior extends Hero {
    // Adding a constructor
    constructor(name, level, weapon) {
        // Access and call function from parent
        super(name, level);

        this.weapon = weapon;
    }
}

Finally, we'll add a method to the extended class.

class Hero {}

class Warrior extends Hero {
  constructor(name, level, weapon) {
    super(name, level)

    this.weapon = weapon
  }

  // Adding a method
  attack() {
    return `${this.name} attacks with the ${this.weapon}.`
  }
}

Now that the class and extended class blueprints are ready, we can create a new character that has acesss to the parameters and methods of the original class and the extended class.

// Initialize individual character instance
const hero1 = new Warrior('Bjorn', 1, 'axe')

console.log(hero1.attack())
console.log(hero1.greet())

The full code and output for JS constructor functions and classes, and PHP classes is below.

JavaScript ES6 Class

The class keyword was introduced with ES6. Classes are built on prototypes in JavaScript.

classes-es6.js
class Hero {
  constructor(name, level) {
    this.name = name
    this.level = level
  }

  greet() {
    return `${this.name} says hello.`
  }
}

class Warrior extends Hero {
  constructor(name, level, weapon) {
    // Access and call function from parent
    super(name, level)

    this.weapon = weapon
  }

  attack() {
    return `${this.name} attacks with the ${this.weapon}.`
  }
}

// Initialize individual character instance
const hero1 = new Warrior('Bjorn', 1, 'axe')

console.log(hero1.attack())
console.log(hero1.greet())
Output
Bjorn attacks with the axe.
Bjorn says hello.

JavaScript ES5 Constructor Function

JavaScript constructor functions were created as an attempt to bring the functionality of traditional object-oriented class design to the JavaScript language.

constructor-functions-es5.js
function Hero(name, level) {
  this.name = name
  this.level = level
}

function Warrior(name, level, weapon) {
  // Access and call function from parent
  Hero.call(this, name, level)

  this.weapon = weapon
}

// Link prototypes and add prototype methods
Warrior.prototype = Object.create(Hero.prototype)

Hero.prototype.greet = function () {
  return this.name + ' says hello.'
}

Warrior.prototype.attack = function () {
  return this.name + ' attacks with the ' + this.weapon + '.'
}

// Initialize individual character instance
const hero1 = new Warrior('Bjorn', 1, 'axe')

console.log(hero1.attack())
console.log(hero1.greet())
Output
Bjorn attacks with the axe.
Bjorn says hello.

PHP Class

Here is a simple example of a PHP class constructor.

class-php.php

<?php

class Hero {
    public function __construct($name, $level) {
        $this->name = $name;
        $this->level = $level;
    }
    public function greet() {
        return "{$this->name} says hello.";
    }
}

class Warrior extends Hero {
    public function __construct($name, $level, $weapon) {
        // Access and call function from parent
        parent::__construct($name, $level, $weapon);

        $this->weapon = $weapon;
    }

    public function attack() {
        return "{$this->name} attacks with the {$this->weapon}.";
    }
}

// Initialize individual character instances
$hero1 = new Warrior('Bjorn', 1, 'axe');

echo $hero1->attack();
echo $hero1->greet();
Output
Bjorn attacks with the axe.
Bjorn says hello.

Of course, JavaScript classes are "syntactic sugar" (ugh) over prototypes, which means under the hood, ES6 classes are not actually running on an object-oriented inheritance model. However, popular libraries like React tend to make a lot of use of classes, so they're good to know. The PHP example shows an actual class from a traditional object-oriented system, but with this simple example, we can get the same output either way.

Personally, I prefer syntactic salt.

Comments